I recently acquired the Sharp MD-MT831 from an
eBay auction. I have been a fan of minidiscs for
a few years now, and this is the second Sharp MD
unit that I have owned, and the third minidisc
recorder I have purchased in the past two years.
Because most of the Sharp models share the same
features, like track-editing, optical/analog
inputs, 4 stage bass DSP, on-the-fly record level
adjustment, etc. etc., I won't go into those
aspects of the 831 here. As I mentioned, it
shares virtually all the same features as the 7xx
series, and even the MS200 before that.
What I will go into is a brief description of the
unit's less technical aspects, and why I am so
impressed with it.
APPEARANCE: When I finally opened the box and
took out the 831, I was astonished at how small
it is. It is so small that I almost worry about
losing it around the house! The anodized
aluminum casing feels strong and durable -- I
have the blue one and it is a very nice color.
The silver is nice too, I'm sure, but I've only
seen it in pictures. The controls are small but
manageable. The LCD display is a nice size and
is easy to read. The whole unit is very "sexy" --
it's kinda plain in appearance but futuristic-
looking just the same! And best of all, it's so
small you can put it in your pocket and barely
know it's there!
SOUND QUALITY: The reason why I upgraded my old
Sharp to the 831 is the ATRAC 7.0 and 24-bit A/D
converters, as well as the reduction in size...I
have to admit that I have not noticed a huge
difference in sound quality from my old Sharp,
but the sound is fantastic nonetheless. I
attribute this to the quality of the Sharp ATRAC,
which IMHO is a little better than Sony's. The
headphone pre-amp on the 831 is very quiet,
almost noiseless, and the bass is clear and clean.
OTHER COMMENTS: The supplied headphones are the
cheap mini-earbud type, which I hate, so I
haven't even used them. Instead I use my $100
Grado headphones and am able to enjoy the great
sound of the 831. The iMac-style charger
is "cute"-looking, but it's really just a plastic
docking station for power and that's it.
The remote is very tiny, and has a nice backlit
LCD screen, and even has a little fish
screensaver that swims around while you're
listening to tunes! I really like the small size
of the remote -- it would be great for "stealth"
recordings, which I plan to do in the future.
You can pause recordings and adjust record levels
with it, which is great! Unfortunately, the
remote, despite all its coolness, feels a little
plasticky and toy-like. It doesn't seem all that
durable because the plastic parts are so light
and small -- I suppose a person would have to be
a little extra careful with it.
SUMMARY: I know people have their preferences
between Sony or Sharp, and I can totally
sympathize with Sony-heads, but honestly, for a
price-to-feature ratio, the Sharp is a great
machine. Sony might make the world's smallest MD
recorder, but the Sharp is a real close second.
And you get all the same features, and even some
features unique to the 831, like NO end-search,
simple real-time recording level adjustments, 4
stage bass DSP, and the latest ATRAC 7.0 from
Sharp (I believe Sony is still using the now-
stale ATRAC 4.5 in their portables)!
The 831 completely rocks, dominates, and kicks
major MD arse!
Okay, i feel it might be helpful to some if there
is a review for this sucker (to complement the
actually quite good one done by Rob Thompson).
Anyways, here's the basic rundown.
Size: Quite small, i actually wouldn't feel
comfortable with much smaller, it's a teense bit
smaller than a sony r55, and also a bit thinner.
Some people mistook it for an r55 when they didnt
get a good look at it, so i assume they are very
similar in size.
Looks: DEFINITELY GET IT IN BLUE. It looks
absolutely fabulous in blue, i feel silver gets a
bit boring over time, but the blue stays
interesting forever. Also it is a very clean
simple design, and is a definite crowd pleaser
(at least among my peers).
Design: The buttons are a bit small, but are
quite useable, and whence you get used to them,
they are quite easy to use. The LCD is very large
and very clear. The letters are large and all the
indicators are easy to see and read. The meter i
find to be more accurate than previous models,
and also quite useful. I would definitely rate it
superior to any sony unit's LCD, which i find to
be a bit too cluttered and the meter to be next
to useless. I like the eject mechanism on the
Sharp quite a bit, when you push a disc in, it
will click, and then you can just push the lid
down and the disk will not pop out. I have found
with sony units i have had around the house (my
friends woudl forget em at my house) that you
have to hold the disc while pushing the cover
down. I can't remember if the sony r90 was that
way too, but i would assume that you'd have to
hold the disc since it has that one touch eject
system. All the ports are in very convenient
placement, I am especially glad that the line out
and the mic in are on opposite sides, it saves
confusion in the dark and i just think it's
overall nicer.
Features: Very nice features...and quite a good
value for them. Sharp ATRAC v7, which i find to
be quite superior to Sony ATRAC 4.5 typeR (at
least to me, and no the r90 does not have typeR,
it has regular 4.5). I think it might have the
dual-rail output like the st-50 instead of the
older condenser type outputs. I have noticed that
the 831 sounds noticeable more clear and spacious
than my old 722. Also the tones are deeper. It is
extremely easy to TOC clone, look on the Minidisc
units board from a while back and youll see me
explain how to do it. It TOC reads very very fast
as well, which is pretty nice, and also for some
reason seems to have anti shock while recording
as well. Also, the thing that would easily make
me buy a sharp over the sony, it can charge while
recording or playing....which is very useful to
me. I suppose there are advantages of the
sony....i'm just not familiar with them. Ack,
okay this review may be a bit biased, but I feel
that the 831 is the most functional unit in
comparison to any other sharp or sony.
Battery Life: Not sure exactly what it is, but i
only have to charge it once a week or week adn a
half, and i use it every day for an hour or two a
day. I would probably guess that it is around 12
hours or so, perhaps 14.
Overall sound: The sound is much more wide than
any other portable that i have used, which is
sometimes a bad thing because some recordings
will sound too soft. However I find in general
that it is a great asset, especially in live
recordings and classical music, as well as
acoustic. It has a much greater amount of detail
than any other portable i have used. I think it
could stand to have a bit louder output, but the
output is not unsatisfactory at all, it's
actually great, but sometimes i guess i listen to
music at abnormally high levels when listening to
like....offspring (hehe!).
Other stuff: The supplied earbuds are okay, they
are definitely the best for factory earbuds, but
that doesnt mean much. It's actually because of
the shape and not the driver units though, when
my old ed-238's broke, i kept the earpads, so i
slapped em onto these sharp things and the sound
was actually very good. Oh well, not many people
have those earpad thingies though. Like with any
unit, you'll probably end up buying other
headphones (I personally reccomend Sony MDR-
ED268LP earbuds, they seem to be very much
attuned to the 831's sound characteristics). The
charging stand is very neato, i like it a lot.
The remote is quite useable, and nice, although i
still favor the 722's remote, i just like that
neato round shape and also how the lcd is
transparent on it and it rests over a vlue
indiglo backing (yes it is quite apparent that it
is transparent...neat that rhymes). However i'd
still take the 831 over the 722 (hehe).
Alright, i think that covers it...
In essence anyone would be basically euphoric
with this unit. Okay, maybe not everyone...but it
still is a great.
After scouring the High Street and the Net for a
portable MD recorder for the last few months, I
finally stumbled upon the Sharp MDMT831. This
unit currently retails for around £200 in the UK,
which was way outside my budget. Had I not bought
it for a bargain one-day only price of 129.99 I
probably would have gone for the cheaper mid-
range Sony MZR70. Anyway, more about that later.
I have been using the unit for about a day or so
now, which is probably not enough to give a good
overall view on it, but I can say initial
impressions are very good. The unit comes with a
flashy remote with some fancy features like a
fish screensaver if the current track does not
have a title. I also liked the blue colour of the
backlight which makes things very easy to see in
poor light conditions.
The unit records very well of a CD player. I have
made copies off CD's which were themselves first
generation copies anyway, and only the most
hardened hi-fi nut will notice the difference in
sound quality here as there is little or no loss
in sound quality through digital recording.
Overall the unit looks, plays, and records great
(it even has a recording level which you can set.
I havent had time to play around with this, but I
guess this is especially useful in live
recordings!).
One big letdown I have noticed so far with the
unit is that it won't allow you to title your
recordings while they are being played! What a
joke! If I had paid the full RRP for this unit
(200 UKP) I would certainly be concerned about
this as it is actually annoying, but seeing as I
got the unit at a knockdown price I am personally
not too bothered about this little 'feature'. It
is a little baffling however, that Sharp have
failed to implement this feature on what was
until recently their top of the range MD
portable! I mean, even the low end Sony's allow
you to title MD's while playing, so I dont
understand why Sharp left it out.
Also, as with most units, the 831 comes with a
basic set of earphones. Surely manufacturers out
there can afford to supply some decent earphones
at a price like this? Oh well, wishful thinking i
suppose.
Last, but not least, as I mentioned above, the
sound quality is superb, as long as you use some
decent headphones or earphones! I also briefly
owned a Sony MZR70 a while back, and I would say
sound quality is similar, if only slightly better
on the Sharp. But then that is to be expected on
what is generally a more expensive 'higher' range
unit.
Finally, would I recommend this unit to others?
Yes definitely, although I would say only buy one
if you can get it a lot cheaper than the RRP. I
personally don't see it good value to buy this
recorder at the full price seeing as it doesnt
even let you title MD's during playback! If
this 'feature' doesnt bother you too much, then I
would buy the Sharp over any Sony any day,
because the battery life of the Sharp is much
superior to even the top of the range Sony
MXR90/91.
I hope this review was helpful to those thinking
of buying an MD. If you are in the UK it is
definitely worth keeping an eye out in What Hi Fi
magazine for Richer Sounds adverts as they often
advertise prices much cheaper than the high
street.
Let me start by saying I'm not an audiophile.
My goal was to find an extremely small, portable,
rugged and attractive minidisc recorder. After
doing the standard research on the web, and also
checking out the devices available in local
stores, I chose to buy the Sharp MD-MT 831. I
made my decision based on perceived reliability.
The only other machine in the game was the
competing Sony R-90, and it didn't feel solid
enough, not did reviewers suggest that it was.
I owe a debt of gratitude to Brian Youn for helping me evaluate the machines and get a
manual in English. Even if he does prefer the
Sony!
One warning... I was ripped-off the first time I
tried to buy the device on E-Bay. Like a dummy, I
sent cash the way half way around the world.
Months later, the guy tells me he's still
patiently waiting for the money to arrive. Right.
Here are my reactions to the Sharp. Again,
remember that I'm no audiophile, so I'm not going
to pretend to pick out the discrete subtleties of
the sound that others say they can.
Appearance: I got the metallic blue one, and I'm
happy that I did. I always carry it in the
provided case, and so I've seen no wearing away
of the coating. I'm fairly conservative in my
tastes, so picking the blue over the silver was a
big deal, but I think I made the right choice. I
have no problems with the controls. But I did
have to search the web and rely on the kindness
of strangers (see above) to get an operator's
manual in English.
Use: The buttons are clearly labeled in English.
Again, they've held up well in the year or so
since I bought it. The unit still feels like it's
in mint condition. I got an optical digital CD
player so that I could record my minidiscs with
optical digital sound. It's been incredibly easy
to record. It's a simple two-step process where
you play the CD and set an audio record level...
then hit the sync button, restart your CD and
away we go. I've never had any problems (other
than occasionally forgetting how and having to
refer to the manual!) The three-level bass button
is useful. Playing back through ear-buds sounds
tinny without an elevated bass. But playing the
thing through my car speakers sounded terrible,
until I turned off the bass completely, at which
point it sounded great. When using Sony MDR-V600
headphones, I keep the bass at level one. By the
way, I'm very happy with these headphones.
Overall the audio quality is first rate as far as
I'm concerned. Clean, no extraneous noise, full.
I haven't bothered with labeling CD's or tracks,
so I'm afraid I can't tell you anything about
that feature. Sticky labels on the outside of the
minidiscs are enough for me... I don't really
like fiddling with small controls. I never use
the remote, so I have no feedback there, either.
The machine is pretty quiet when it's running...
I've never heard it above the music... and even
when I don't have headphones on the noise isn't
terribly noticeable. Plus, as I said, I keep it
in the case, which muffles any possible sound.
Battery life is fine when I'm only playing back.
But it's significantly shorter if I also record.
I keep a careful eye on the battery meter... I
find I can play perhaps 1/2 hour after it's on
empty.
Rugged? I use the Sharp while I'm exercising and
when I'm driving. Unlike my portable CD player,
the Sharp doesn't skip when I'm driving. It's had
rock solid sound since the beginning. My exercise
is on a machine, so there's not a lot of bouncing
around. I worry that I might someday get clumsy
while loading a minidisc and somehow damage the
mechanism. As with all of these tiny devices
(including my Sony DRC-PC5 Digital video camera)
the mechanism for accepting a tape is made of
very thin metal... it seems to me it could easily
be bent. So I'm always careful when I insert a
disc.
Overall, I'm very happy with my purchase. I think
I bought the right device for my needs. As I
said, I'm pretty conservative when I buy stuff...
so my knee-jerk reaction was to buy a Sony. I
didn't trust Sharp's reliability. But so far,
I've had no reason to regret my decision. I hope
something in all of this helps you make your
choice.